Catavino keeps you current not only with the remarkable wine developments in Spain and Portugal, two of the most dynamic wine producers on the planet, but you'll learn about food trends, new dishes and restaurants and the ancient and modern cultures on the Iberian Peninsula. And you may not notice it, but Catavino also happens to be one of smoothest designed websites you'll have the pleasure of visiting.
Doug Frost MS/MW http://dougfrost.com

Organic Spanish Wines Fight the Sulfite Battle

Sulfite Structure – image via 

ORGANIC WINES FIGHT THE SULFITES BATTTLE or
WHAT! THIS IS ORGANIC?

“Get out your un-bleached, hypoallergenic, 100% soy, macrobiotic light-sabers!”, said the organic wine, “we’re going into battle”.

No, it’s not what you think. If you live in Boulder, Colorado, home of everything organic, you probably don’t even bat an eyelash at the growing proliferation of organic wines in the market today. I, in fact, was not surprised in the least during a recent trip to Boulder to be invited to have dinner with a successful organic wine importer. What did knock my socks off however, was the fact that one of the wines that he brought along to dinner was Spanish, and not only that, but it was from the well-known Catalan winery Albet i Noya, and not only that, but I had sold it in my restaurant for years without ever suspecting that it was organic!

In the United States it really seems that you can’t shake a stick without hitting a label that touts the description “organic”. From beef jerky to cottage cheese to heel cream, so much so that while I secretly prefer to buy organic meats and dairy for example, I publicly scoff at it, and have my doubts about how much of these “organic” labels really mean what they say, and if they do, what does THAT mean anyway. Therefore, I have never been surprised to see American wines with the word “organic” on their label, I just thought it was the thing to do. Finding out, via an Italian importer however, that one of my preferred wines from the Penedés region is actually an organic wine, got me to thinking. What does this all mean?

First of all, I really thought that all wines were organic. They are made from grapes, it is a naturally occurring fermentation process, it has been around for 4000 years etc. what can be more “organic” than that? One of the keys to classifying a wine as organic is the quantity of sulfites in the wine. As explained in my last Myth Busting article about sulfites, all wines contain sulfites, and one of the myths about organic wines is that they don’t contain any sulfites at all. However, aside from being a naturally occurring substance in the wine (and in the human body), sulfites are still permitted in organic wines because they are needed to protect the growing grapes from disease and to preserve and stabilize the wines. The difference is therefore in the quantity. In the United States, organic wines are permitted up to 100 g/ml of sulfites (regular wines up to 350 mg/l) although the majority contain much less. With a quantity any higher than 10 mg/l, the wines are still required to have that pesky “contains sulfites” label even though they are also considered “organic”. In Spain, organic wines are known as “vinos ecologicos” and they are allowed varying sulfite quantities depending on the region as long as it doesn’t interfere with the virtually impossible to find European Union standards.

Aside from the sulfite levels in the wines, there are many other factors that lead a wine to be considered organic or “ecologico”. This has to do with the treatments that the vines receive in the vineyard as far as pesticides and the use of chemicals is concerned. According to Albet i Noya for example, “The principal characteristics of organically grown grapes are the lack of chemical residues and ideal sanitary conditionsâ€Â¦ Organic regulations therefore prohibit any kind of treatments with synthetic chemical products (herbicides, pesticides or fertilizers).” Organic wine laws limit the kind of treatment that a vineyard may receive, the products used, and even the time of year that the treatment is carried out.

It is interesting to note however, that all of these factors: low sulfite levels, restricted use of pesticides, good farming techniques, lack of chemical additives, etc. are common practices in most wineries that produce high quality wines. As I pointed out in the previous article, the better the grapes are cared for in a vineyard, than the smaller the amount of added sulfites that are needed. The same is true for the other practices. Vineyards that produce fine wines tend to have lower grape yields, for example, and again according to Albet i Noya, “low yields in the vineyards not only improve the quality of the grapes, but also improve the sustainability of the vineyards as the vines are naturally more resistant to plagues”, therefore leading to a decreased need for pesticides.

So then why is it that I had no idea that Albet i Noya’s wines were organic? I carried their wines in my restaurant for four years? The reason seems to be that the organic craze just hasn’t made it to Spain yet. The organic supermarket trend is just catching on here while in other countries such as Germany, and France (the largest organic wine producer in the world) it has been around forever. For me at least, the fact that I buy almost all of my meat and produce at the farmer’s market, a typical practice in Spain, makes it all seem pretty organic without it necessarily being so. In fact, organic products still seem almost subversive here, only to be found in “special” health food stores, where products like vegetables and meats are scarce and cost prohibitive. Therefore, while wineries might use all ecological practices, they seldom advertise their products in Spain based on their ecological status, although it seems that this practice is growing on a daily basis, which explains why we might be jumping on the organic bus to Boulder, without even having bought a ticket.

-Adrienne Smith

Two Notes from Albet i Noya:

Albet i Noya. Col.lecció Tempranillo 1999. DO Penedés
rich velvety texture, full-body, smooth, black cherries, spices, complex intense fruit mingled with smoky woody tones.

4 grape

Alar de Sorolla. 50% Garnacha, 50% Syrah. Aragón.
With only .05 mg added sulfites, this curious and intensely colored wine boasts initial aromas of fruit, reminiscent of ripe caramel candy apples, Halloween and everything autumnal. Good acidity and slight toasted notes from its 4 months aged in wood.

3 grape

Author’s note: at Bodegas Cueva in DO Utiel-Requeña, I tasted their 2001 Crianza, and this wine, the vintner’s own – not available for sale, but too interesting to not mention here.

Bodegas Cueva. Personal Blend. 100% Bobal.
No added sulfites. Dark, intense, robust and meaty, what this wine lacks in aromas it more than makes up for in the mouth where it comes alive – infused with lavender, rosemary, thyme, pine, nuts, chocolate, and an overwhelming hazlenutty almost Nutella flavor. Almost too much on its own, it would be excellent with a soft intense cheese such as Torta de Casar. A really interesting and unique wine – hope he starts producing it for the rest of us to buy.

3 grape

Search here for other tasting notes from Albet i Noya : Albet i Noya TN’s

  • Pingback: Catavino - Spanish Wine, Portuguese wine and more! » Wine Labeling Law()

  • Marsha

    I think you are wrong when you say the NOP allows sulfites to be added to grapes used to make organic wine. This is the National List link: <a href="http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/ListReg…“><a href="http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standard…” target=”_blank”>http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/ListReg…This is what the rule says: Sulfur dioxide – for use only in wine labeled "made with organic grapes," Provided, That, total sulfite concentration does not exceed 100 ppm. So if sulfites have been used to treat the grapes, they can be used to make, for example, "Pinot Noir — Made with Organic Grapes" but can not be used to make "Organic Pinot Noir".

  • Marsha

    I think you are wrong when you say the NOP allows sulfites to be added to grapes used to make organic wine. This is the National List link: <a href="http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/ListReg…“><a href="http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standard…” target=”_blank”>http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/ListReg…This is what the rule says: Sulfur dioxide – for use only in wine labeled "made with organic grapes," Provided, That, total sulfite concentration does not exceed 100 ppm. So if sulfites have been used to treat the grapes, they can be used to make, for example, "Pinot Noir — Made with Organic Grapes" but can not be used to make "Organic Pinot Noir".

  • Marsha

    I think you are wrong when you say the NOP allows sulfites to be added to grapes used to make organic wine. This is the National List link: <a href="http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/ListReg…“><a href="http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standard…” target=”_blank”>http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/ListReg…This is what the rule says: Sulfur dioxide – for use only in wine labeled "made with organic grapes," Provided, That, total sulfite concentration does not exceed 100 ppm. So if sulfites have been used to treat the grapes, they can be used to make, for example, "Pinot Noir — Made with Organic Grapes" but can not be used to make "Organic Pinot Noir".

  • Marsha

    I think you are wrong when you say the NOP allows sulfites to be added to grapes used to make organic wine.

    This is the National List link: http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards/ListReg.html

    This is what the rule says:

    Sulfur dioxide – for use only in wine labeled “made with organic grapes,” Provided, That, total sulfite concentration does not exceed 100 ppm.

    So if sulfites have been used to treat the grapes, they can be used to make, for example, “Pinot Noir — Made with Organic Grapes” but can not be used to make “Organic Pinot Noir”.

  • Padraic

    Thanks for the article on organics. I wish you would have stopped by Boulder Liquor Mart and taken a peek at our selection of over 100 Organic, Biodynamic and Sustainably grown wines. The market here really supports the category as you very well have seen. It's a fun up and coming category that we love to promote! Cheers,

  • Padraic

    Thanks for the article on organics. I wish you would have stopped by Boulder Liquor Mart and taken a peek at our selection of over 100 Organic, Biodynamic and Sustainably grown wines. The market here really supports the category as you very well have seen. It’s a fun up and coming category that we love to promote!

    Cheers,